New
Mar 18, 4:34 PM
#1
utopia-
Offline
Sep 2024
422
So what do you think? Is there any salvation in this even if the animation is bad? Taking into account the team behind the sound, direction, script...?
Mar 18, 5:03 PM
#2
MiriSugo
Offline
Aug 2024
23
After blue lock s2 anything is good animation to me lol. I will be watching tbate though
Mar 18, 5:05 PM
#3
MiriSugo
Offline
Aug 2024
23
utopia- said:
We already know about the animation being bad. But is there a chance that the adaptation will still be acceptable? Like, if even with the bad animation, the script and rhythm are good, the sound, and the way it's conducted is somewhat coherent, is there a chance that it could be good? Of course I say this analyzing the team behind the anime, Does this team know how to conduct anime scripts coherently? Because depending on how this continues throughout the episodes, perhaps, even if it is something almost impossible, this doesn't end up being so disappointing.
So what do you think? Is there any salvation in this even if the animation is bad? Taking into account the team behind the sound, direction, script...?
Im assuming the score will float somewhere around a 8.27 - 8.42. which is nothing bad at all. Will be interesting to see once it airs
Mar 18, 5:05 PM
#4
u-Anand__
Offline
Dec 2020
47
Yeah it’s not looking good
Mar 18, 5:07 PM
#5
IhnalakoKaina
Offline
Jul 2021
233
Looking at what the direction (director and series composition, and one of them is probably also the script writer) has made in the past, I'm expecting this adaptation to be carried by the source (if it's really as good as people have made it out to be), and therefore quite disappointing for source readers but not too bad for anime only people.
Pretty much like Kikansha no Mahou, which had the same guy do series composition. In that case, the animation sucked, the pacing was a bit off (kinda slow), the script lacked drama and impact, and the music was passable.
Mar 18, 5:54 PM
#6
kekotron
Offline
Oct 2024
19
I trust, the animation will be trash but they'll animate incredibly some fight one the last episode and it will get a second season (I'm not delusional)
Mar 18, 6:26 PM
#7
Spleefy
Offline
Dec 2020
104
MiriSugo said:
I dont understand how the animation is bad. I saw a tiny bit of the trailer and it didnt look bad. I probably dont got a good eye for things like that though.
After blue lock s2 anything is good animation to me lol. I will be watching tbate though
There was just a lack of overall movement in the trailer.
Mar 18, 6:30 PM
#8
Merve2Love
Offline
Apr 2020
3228
Does it help? Sure. Did Mushoku Tensei look good, at times? Yeah.
But I think that's generaly not what makes people love the Genre and there are tons of similar Anime that didn't need to rely on a big studio to draw people in. That Spider-Show or Eminence in Shadow come to mind.
Don't give up, boys.
Merve2LoveMar 18, 6:34 PM
Mar 18, 7:20 PM
#9
otakupro68
Online
Sep 2024
38
MiriSugo said:
utopia- said:
We already know about the animation being bad. But is there a chance that the adaptation will still be acceptable? Like, if even with the bad animation, the script and rhythm are good, the sound, and the way it's conducted is somewhat coherent, is there a chance that it could be good? Of course I say this analyzing the team behind the anime, Does this team know how to conduct anime scripts coherently? Because depending on how this continues throughout the episodes, perhaps, even if it is something almost impossible, this doesn't end up being so disappointing.
So what do you think? Is there any salvation in this even if the animation is bad? Taking into account the team behind the sound, direction, script...?
Im assuming the score will float somewhere around a 8.27 - 8.42. which is nothing bad at all. Will be interesting to see once it airs
Although the animation might be a bit of a disappointment(emphasis on might), the storyline and characters will distinguish it from the other generic isekai. I don't know if it will get up to an 8, though. I think the MAL score will range from 7-7.75 at best.
Mar 18, 7:21 PM
#10
otakupro68
Online
Sep 2024
38
Also, TBATE wasn't targeted to a japan market, so it getting an anime is fortunate, to be honest. At the very least, it can make people likely to turn to the source material.
Mar 18, 8:03 PM
#11
TheLastCrusaders
Offline
Nov 2020
121
The animation will turn most people off from watching it.Honestly just looks like most generic isekai nowadays.
Mar 18, 10:24 PM
#12
LostSpectre
Offline
Jan 2013
6500
It might still be alright if the story is good enough to carry it, but yeah, it's likely going to have animation on par with typical trash seasonals.
If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that.
Mar 18, 10:38 PM
#13
SoloNecromancer
Offline
Mar 2021
528
i think we should just wait few day's
who knows
Anime Rules the world
Mar 19, 3:41 AM
#14
hypexleaks
Offline
Apr 2021
253
kekotron said:
I trust, the animation will be trash but they'll animate incredibly some fight one the last episode and it will get a second season (I'm not delusional)
studio a-cat isn't known for delivering any sakuga animation or anything remotely considered good yet, abandon any hope even if its .5% because it's just not possible with that disgusting studio 😭
Mar 19, 3:44 AM
#15
hypexleaks
Offline
Apr 2021
253
MiriSugo said:
utopia- said:
We already know about the animation being bad. But is there a chance that the adaptation will still be acceptable? Like, if even with the bad animation, the script and rhythm are good, the sound, and the way it's conducted is somewhat coherent, is there a chance that it could be good? Of course I say this analyzing the team behind the anime, Does this team know how to conduct anime scripts coherently? Because depending on how this continues throughout the episodes, perhaps, even if it is something almost impossible, this doesn't end up being so disappointing.
So what do you think? Is there any salvation in this even if the animation is bad? Taking into account the team behind the sound, direction, script...?
Im assuming the score will float somewhere around a 8.27 - 8.42. which is nothing bad at all. Will be interesting to see once it airs
way too high, the story at the beginning is already generic asf as is and identical to mushoku tensei, the 'good animation' is what's needed to carry this slow part of the story out
without that, you're basically getting the same slop that you get every season with newer isekai. I do expect the rating to be higher, but nothing more than a 7.5, even then I think a 7.5 is being generous lol
Mar 19, 5:03 AM
#16
damin34
Offline
May 2016
1
In recent season we had the same situation with ENGI adapting Medalist, but they delivered really well. This time it's even worse studio but I will wait for episodes before judging how bad it is.
Mar 19, 7:20 AM
#17
Sworup_Ackerman
Offline
Jan 2025
10
fr, my first and favorite Manhwa.The anime adaptation looks disappointing... but we gotta hope. But the Manhwa is so good, it's Peak infact. My Goat King Grey🛐. WE ALL SHOUT AND CHEER FOR WHO??? ARTHUR LEYWIN!!!🗣️🗣️🗣️
Mar 19, 1:54 PM
#18
-DxP-
Community Mod
Equanimity
Offline
Nov 2020
1641
Why aren't you all waiting for the first episode? What's the point of speculation? Even if the animation isn't superb,I feel like if they don't rush the story and stay true to the source the anime will be quite passable, regardless of the animation. I'm surprised enough that Tbate is getting an anime anyway, I would have never expected that.
| How to Become a MAL Moderator
Mar 19, 2:03 PM
#19
Yumi_Karoni
Offline
Jun 2022
24
I can't stay positive everything of this teaser is a red flag this will be very diasppoiting for the fans I doubt the score will be more than 7.
Mar 19, 11:21 PM
#20
adbeaver
Offline
Mar 2015
840
I just hope there's not going to be any slideshows pleasee
Mar 19, 11:55 PM
#21
MirkoAnime22
Offline
Sep 2024
24
The trailer is looking not that bad. I think the animation will be alright. Not every studio has the animation qualities like MAPPA or ufotable. The expectations are nowadays a bit too high. This is just a trailer, there is no need to judge an whole anime that even doesn't aired yet just by the trailer. So we will be good when we wait for the first three episodes and judge after finishing watching them. I'm looking forward for this anime and I'm ready for an entertaining anime.
Yesterday, 8:59 AM
#22
Kerustory
Offline
Aug 2020
5
from the trailer i just watched,it doesn't look even close to mushoku tensei. the song,the animation,the vibe and everything..i thought it would be a cool adaptation since everyone keeps talking crazy about it. it's just another flop isekai anime
Yesterday, 2:49 PM
#23
neko237
Offline
Dec 2015
6
another isekai slop flop, safe skip
8 hours ago
#24
TheSekiryuutei
Offline
Aug 2014
158
this series ain't even that popular, you got to have minimum at least 1 billion readers before it can even be popular you damn losers.
See All Discussions
More topics from this board
» Anime adaptationToutou908 - Mar 13 | 17 | by Oongbuh »» 8 hours ago | |
» It's Studio A-Cat , Hope is lostArvin_Washbear - Feb 17 | 24 | by Mattinator95 »» Mar 18, 4:35 AM | |
» New PvItsukisayo - Mar 5 | 28 | by Tokoya »» Mar 14, 10:18 AM | |
» Such a shameNotoriousAkh - Mar 7 | 11 | by SoloNecromancer »» Mar 12, 4:16 AM | |
» TBATE Web Novel Entry In MALAce_2020 - Oct 20, 2024 | 14 | by AMBITZZ »» Mar 7, 3:49 AM |
